Dear Tacit,
A friend of mine used AI to help her figure out how to cope with some problems she was having. Do you think this is a good alternative to counselling?
Signed: Can AI Replace Counselling?
Dear Can AI Replace Counselling,
Artificial intelligence is showing up everywhere these days. And that includes the use of AI options in the mental health world. AI-powered chatbots, apps, and tools now offer everything from mood tracking to guided conversations that can sometimes look a bit like therapy. In some situations, (for therapists and clients alike), this is exciting and empowering. At other times, it raises serious concerns. Like most technologies, using AI as a tool for mental wellness has both benefits and drawbacks. And you have to decide for yourself if this new type of support can truly help your unique situation. Here are some things to perhaps consider:
One of the biggest advantages of AI tools is its accessibility. Counselling can be expensive, hard to schedule, or unavailable in some areas. AI apps are usually accessible 24/7, which means a person can reach out for support in the middle of the night or during a stressful moment without needing to wait. For people who feel overwhelmed taking the first step in finding support, this low barrier can make a real difference.
Talking about mental health can be difficult for some people. AI might feel less intimidating than opening up to another human, especially at first. There’s no fear of judgment or awkward silences. And there are lots of opportunities for re-do’s. This can help users practice expressing their thoughts and emotions more openly, which may make it easier for them to talk to a therapist or a trusted friend, at another time.
Private therapy options can be costly, and insurance coverage is often limited. Many AI mental health tools are free or significantly cheaper than in-person counselling. While they’re not a replacement for real professional help/treatment, they can offer basic coping strategies, reflections, or emotional support to people who might otherwise have nothing.
AI tools are often good at pattern recognition. Mood trackers and journaling apps can help users notice trends in their emotions, sleep, stress levels, or triggers, if they are used regularly over time. This kind of insight can be valuable, whether someone is managing their mental health on their own or working alongside a professional. AI is more like a “coach” of sorts – and this can be a very useful support to have on an ongoing basis.
But no matter how natural an AI conversation may feel, AI does not truly understand human emotions. It doesn’t have empathy, lived experience, or intuition. It responds superficially (based on patterns and data) and can only respond to what the user is asking (it’s difficult to be able to ask what we are unaware of), which means it can miss the nuance, context, or the emotional weight of a situation. For complex or deeply personal struggles, this limitation matters a great deal.
Because AI systems rely on data and patterns rather than real understanding, they sometimes end up giving responses that are inaccurate, overly generic, or not appropriate for a person’s specific situation. An AI tool might offer advice that sounds reasonable but isn’t actually helpful (esp. if a person is trying to grow in a new direction or tackle their problems in a different way). Small errors can feel frustrating or invalidating to the user. The person may also not easily recognize when these errors are happening and can be led down the wrong pathway, where more harm can occur.
AI tools are also not designed to handle mental health emergencies. In situations involving severe distress, complex mental health disorders, self-harm, or suicidal thoughts, relying on AI can be risky. A trained therapist knows how to properly assess risk, adapt in real time, and provide appropriate intervention in ways that AI simply cannot.
Mental health data is deeply personal. Using AI often means sharing thoughts, feelings, and habits with an app or platform. Even with privacy policies in place, there are valid concerns about how this data is stored, used, or potentially shared. Data hacks happen all the time. And for some users, this alone is a dealbreaker.
AI tools can be helpful, but they can also become a crutch. There’s a risk that people may rely solely on AI for emotional support and avoid seeking human connection or professional help when they truly need it. Isolation is a huge negative when it comes to mental wellness. Mental health often improves through relationships, understanding, and shared experiences—and these are things that AI can’t fully provide.
Using AI as a mental wellness support isn’t inherently good or bad. It’s just a tool. As an experienced and well-trained therapist, I often suggest books, videos, and other resources to my clients (specific to their unique needs), to help them on their counselling journey. Used thoughtfully, AI can be one of these tools. It can offer some support, pattern tracking insight, and comfort, especially for mild stress, anxiety, or self-reflection. But it works best as a supplement, not a substitute, for human care. For deeper healing, diagnosis, or crisis support, trained therapists and trusted humans remain essential (and I am not just saying that because I am one! LOL).
Take care!
Do you have a question you would like us to address? Please feel free to reach out to us at counsellors@tacitknows.com. Your answer will be provided confidentially.
Want to start your counselling today?
Make an Appointment