Dear Tacit,
What is the difference between self-harm behaviours and a suicide attempt?
Signed: Is Self Harm The Same As A Suicide Attempt?
Dear Is Self Harm The Same As A Suicide Attempt,
This is one of those questions that a lot of people wonder about but they don’t always feel comfortable asking (so thank you!). The more we understand about this issue, the more compassionately we can respond to the people we care about (and maybe even support ourselves).
The simple answer is this: self-harm and a suicide attempt are not the same thing. While they can sometimes exist together, the intention behind them is very different.
A suicide attempt involves the intention to end one’s life. Sometimes, the emotional pain a person is feeling becomes so intense that they don’t see any way out of it. It can wear a person down into a state of hopelessness and helplessness.
Our brain naturally craves a sense of control, especially in difficult situations. And when a person can no longer see any options for support or change, they might start to believe that the only freedom or choice they have left is to end their own life.
Self-harm, on the other hand, is usually an attempt to cope with emotional pain – not to die. It might seem confusing, but many people who self-harm are actually trying to find relief from feelings that seem impossible to hold. They’re trying to survive the moment, not necessarily end their life.
(This is not to say that self-harm behaviours can’t result in death. They certainly might – even by accident. And this is why we need to always take them very seriously.)
To help explain why people might turn to self-harming behaviours, we have to understand a bit about how the brain/body works. When our nervous system becomes overwhelmed, it naturally looks for ways to regulate itself. Ideally, we have healthy coping strategies and supportive relationships to help us through difficult emotions.
But when those resources aren’t available, or we haven’t learned ways that truly help, our brain will start to reach for whatever brings even temporary relief (alcohol or drugs, food, gambling, shopping, and direct self-harm behaviours like cutting, scratching/picking, burning, pulling hair, etc). This doesn’t mean these outlets are healthy coping strategies, but it does mean there’s a valid reason behind why it’s happening.
People self-harm for different reasons. For some, it gives them a break from the emotional pain they are carrying by creating a physical pain they can understand and manage more easily. Others might be feeling emotionally numb or disconnected to their own feelings altogether, and they use self-harm just so they can feel something (anything) again. Some people find that the act of self-harm successfully interrupts the barrage of racing thoughts they live with almost constantly, or provides a sense of control when everything else going on feels chaotic.
None of these experiences mean someone is “crazy,” “attention-seeking,” or “being dramatic.” The act of self-harm usually means a person’s nervous system is overloaded and they are doing the best they can to manage with the coping strategies they currently have.
Human beings are wired for connection. When we’re struggling, we need safe people who can help us regulate (not criticism for needing support). If someone is hurting themselves because of the intense emotional pain they are carrying, it’s important that we do not shame them.
In reality, many people who self-harm do everything they can to hide it. They carry an internal guilt or embarrassment or feelings of weakness and failure that often keep them silent for months or even years. Their self-harming behaviours go on far longer than necessary and get more dangerous or damaging as time passes (increasing the risk of permanent injury or accidental death). What the person needs isn’t judgment – it’s empathy and understanding.
That said, self-harm should always be taken seriously. Even when someone isn’t trying to end their life, self-harm tells us they’re carrying more than they can cope with alone. It’s a sign that additional support could make a meaningful difference.
It’s also important to know that people who self-harm have a higher risk of experiencing suicidal thoughts or behaviours than people who don’t (the two issues can happen at the same time). That’s why we never want to dismiss self-harm as “not a big deal,” but we also don’t want to assume we know what it means.
The most helpful thing we can do is become curious instead of making assumptions. Instead of asking, “Why would you do that?” we want to ask, “Can you help me understand what is happening for you?”
Instead of trying to immediately stop the behaviour, we need to try to understand the need that has developed underneath it. Because every behaviour serves a purpose. If we only focus on taking away the behaviour without helping someone develop new ways to regulate difficult emotions, we’ve taken away their coping strategy without replacing it. And the situation can get much worse.
Helping someone who is self-harming isn’t about forcing them to “just stop.” It’s about assisting them as they build enough safety, support, self-awareness, and emotional capacity that they no longer need the harmful strategy in the same way.
If you’re worried that someone who is self-harming may also be thinking about suicide, it’s okay to ask them directly. Asking about suicide does NOT put the idea into someone’s head. More often, it helps the person know they are not alone, and you are willing to talk about the hard things with them. It gives them a critically important, safe support.
And if you’re reading this because these self-harming experiences feel familiar, I want you to know that your behaviours are not your identity. They are just information. They tell us when something inside of us is hurting, overwhelmed, disconnected, or carrying more than it can manage alone. That isn’t something to be ashamed of. It’s something to be curious about.
It’s a sign to reach out for the connection that will be able to help you feel better (in ways that you don’t know how to make happen yourself, yet). Talk to a friend or family member – to a therapist – to a help line. You do not need to go thru this alone.
Remember too that many of us need to adjust our concept of “healthy”. Healing from mental health struggles in our lives isn’t about becoming someone who never struggles. It’s about becoming someone who can stay connected to themselves through the struggle, ask for support, and slowly build new ways of responding to emotional pain.
Take care!
Do you have a question you would like us to address? Please feel free to reach out to us at counsellors@tacitknows.com. Your answer will be provided confidentially.
Do you need some counselling support or some Neurofeedback Training, to help you cope?
Make an Appointment Or contact us thru our email (counsellors@tacitknows.com) for more information.