Dear Tacit,
Can you explain the difference between healthy and unhealthy altruism?
Signed: Just To Be Nice
Dear Just To Be Nice,
Absolutely. The concept of altruism can be generally explained as the desire to help others without expecting anything in return. It’s when we do something kind or generous just because we care, and not because we want a reward or recognition. For example, you might shovel your neighbours driveway or help a stranger carry their groceries, just to be nice.
Healthy altruism is grounded in self-respect and boundaries (we know when to say no; and we recognize and honour our own limits). It is motivated by empathy and compassion. Acts of kindness are freely given, and not driven by guilt or obligation. Because healthy altruism does not require that we sacrifice our own well-being, it is balanced and sustainable. And it encourages and allows growth and independence in others. It is not a pathway to control or dependency or enabling. We can know we are in patterns of healthy altruism when it gives us a sense of joy and satisfaction (it feels emotionally fulfilling) and does not end up causing resentment or burnout.
Unhealthy altruism often stems from guilt, fear, or a need for approval. Helping others becomes compulsive, self-sacrificing, or harmful to ourselves (or to others). Unhealthy altruism results when we are consistently putting the needs of others above our own, leading to emotional or physical exhaustion. It is a reflection of a lack of healthy boundaries – we may struggle to say no, even when we know it’s detrimental to our own care. Unhealthy altruism prevents the other person from addressing their own issues/needs, and developing their own strengths and healthy patterns. We can know we are in patterns of unhealthy altruism when we are feeling underappreciated, used or emotionally drained in the relationship.
If you are not sure if you are in a healthy or unhealthy altruism pattern, start by checking your motives. Ask yourself why you are doing what you are doing, and be as honest with yourself as possible. Make sure your boundaries feel firmly in place and that you are receiving the care, rest and appreciation that you also deserve in your relationships (there must be a healthy level of give and take).
Notice if you are taking on other people’s problems as your own. You can care deeply for someone else but NOT lose yourself in their pain or challenges. Remember too that your value or worthiness is not tied to whether or not you can make someone else happier. If you are regularly feeling exhausted, irritable, or unappreciated, it’s time to step back. Helping others should energize (not deplete) you.
And be sure that you are supporting others in ways that also help/allow them to grow. Don’t do everything for them – teach, guide, and encourage independence. Empowering someone else means they are regularly putting more effort into the situation than you are! We want to be the authors of our own life-story – and so should others get to do the same for themselves (they need to be able to decide what happens in the book that they are writing/living – not us).
There are arguments that say there is no such thing as true altruism because all generous acts are rooted in self-interest. (There is even a Friends episode where Joey proves to Phoebe that there is no such thing as a “truly selfless good deed” LOL) When we are nice to others, we tend to get a good feeling within ourselves, as part of the ripple effect. Or, sometimes we do these kind things in order to look good in front of others. Or maybe we are doing something virtuous for others to make up for something not-so-great that we did/do at another time in our life – or as a reward of sorts, for the after life. But I personally think that a little altruism from all of us makes this world a better place. And as long as we are doing it in a healthy way, I don’t see anything wrong with spreading a little kindness, for any reason!
Take care!
Do you have a question you would like us to address? Please feel free to reach out to us at counsellors@tacitknows.com. Your answer will be provided confidentially.
Want to start your counselling today?
Make an Appointment