Dear Tacit,
I’ve been using social media constantly. I know it’s bad for me, but it’s how I numb out. I’m always comparing myself to others and end up feeling worse. Why can’t I stop even though I know it’s harming my mental health?
Signed: Overusing Social Media
Dear Overusing Social Media,
What you’re describing is a really common problem. Breaking the pattern isn’t just about a lack of willpower. Social media overuse (especially when it’s tied to numbing and self-comparison) taps into several overlapping aspects that make it genuinely hard to stop (or cut back).
Social media is designed to get your brain hooked on the quick dopamine hit (it feeds us new things which triggers the “pay attention!” chemical in our brain). Even when you feel worse afterward, your brain remembers the brief relief or amusement you got in the moment. This makes you reach for it again when you feel bored, anxious, or low.
Social media acts as emotional anesthesia. If you’re stressed, lonely, or overwhelmed, scrolling lets you avoid those uncomfortable feelings for a bit (and that feels good). The brain loves this short-term escape, even if the long-term cost is higher, so you keep repeating it. This is similar to other avoidance behaviors like overeating, drinking, smoking weed, binge-watching shows, over-shopping, etc.
The comparison trap is built-in and automatic. Social media showcases polished slices of other people’s lives. Even knowing it’s not the full truth, your brain compares, because comparison is a deeply wired survival instinct. Repeated comparisons chip away at self-esteem, which ironically makes you more likely to scroll for distraction… and the cycle deepens.
Your habits are on autopilot. Once you’ve linked certain situations (morning coffee, waiting in line, feeling lonely at night) to picking up your phone, your brain starts doing it without conscious thought. This is called a “cue–craving–response–reward” loop, and it’s why the behavior feels automatic.
Stopping feels like a loss. Even if social media makes you feel bad, part of you fears losing connection, missing news, or being “out of the loop.” That perceived loss keeps you from quitting cold turkey. And stopping means the uncomfortable feelings you might be trying to avoid (boredom, stress, overwhelm, etc) suddenly take centre-stage.
Lots of studies have been done on the harmful effects that result from too much social media use. Recently, a study at the University of Texas found that 75% of participants reported significantly improved mental health after just 14 days of decreased scrolling. They noted that people had better sleep patterns, and spent more time spent on hobbies, socializing, and being outside. But most amazingly, they found that attention spans improved as much as reversing 10 years of age-related cognitive decline! And when it came to symptoms of depression, the social media detox outperformed medication and was comparable to cognitive behavioral therapy.
So, here are some ways to help you reduce your use. You need to replace the numbing out with something that actually helps your mood in the long run, without triggering the same comparison spiral. Or you can try a short-term cold-turkey method (not for forever) instead, to help you regain a sense of positive control over your social media use. If a gradual cutback is like turning down the volume, short-term detox is like hitting mute for a while so you remember what calm feels like.
To gradually cut back on your usage, first start by noticing your triggers. When you reach for your phone, are you feeling bored or anxious – is it just before bed or as soon as you wake up? Create a small friction/delay in the automatic process involved to access your apps. Move them to a folder on the last home screen, or log out after each use. Turn off all non-essential notifications. Or delete the app from your phone so you have to reload it every time you want to use it.
Replace the need to numb out by finding a couple of activities that are quick (1–5 minutes) and genuinely soothing or grounding (like stepping outside for some fresh air, creating a stretch break for your body, listening to one song, texting a friend, etc). When you feel the urge to scroll, try the replacement activity first. If you still want to scroll after, you can with no guilt. Over time, your brain learns these other things can give relief too.
Create an intentional schedule for your scrolling. During these two or three short time blocks (15 min or so each), scroll freely. But outside of those windows, make sure your phone stays in Do Not Disturb mode, or keep it in another room.
Be sure to prompt yourself to add a reality check to the scrolling that you do. Before you close the app, pause and name a couple of things that you saw that might be filtered, staged, or exaggerated. And then name one or two things in your own life that’s going well (even if they are small). This can help break the pattern of believing that everyone else’s life is better.
Make the time to track the positive shifts you are making. It’s not enough (at first) to just think about them – you need to see the proof. Mark down the days when you have had less total time online, and the days you have used your replacement activities. Be sure to write down how you felt after these successes. New patterns will start to appear. You will likely see better mood on lighter-use days, which will help reinforce the change you are making.
If you prefer to go with a short-term detox, you can use similar steps to give your brain enough time away from the dopamine rollercoaster so your baseline resets. People usually opt for this method over a 3 to 7-day period, but you can go for 2 weeks if you wish. Define your “off limit” period. Decide if it will be for all social media or just the platforms that trigger you most.
If you decide to still use messaging apps, be sure to mute all group chats. Create a lot of inconvenience by deleting the apps that you are detoxing from completely from your phone. Have a friend change the passwords for you. (If you need the apps for work, use a desktop access only and/or add time-limiting cutoffs.) Keep your phone in another room for long stretches.
Just like with the gradual decrease approach, line up some replacement activities – take short walks, listen to a podcast or an audio book, set up coffee or lunch dates with friends, pick a new (or old) hobby to get into, etc. Expect some withdrawal issues, and cope with them effectively. The first 2–3 days can create a lot of restlessness, boredom and fidgetiness. You might feel anxious or irritable. You are not being dramatic. Your brain is adjusting to less dopamine stimulation. Knowing this is a real and normal response can make it easier to push through.
Just like with the previous approach, make the time to observe how your mood changes without your constant social media comparison. You will want to understand, so you can choose healthier options for managing. When the detox is over, don’t just return to your old patterns again. Create a staggered and limited (healthier) pattern. Consider giving yourself a maximum amount of time each day for social media scrolling, and stick to the specific times during the day that you assign for these intervals. Pick just one or two platforms to return to instead of all of them.
Take care!
Do you have a question you would like us to address? Please feel free to reach out to us at counsellors@tacitknows.com. Your answer will be provided confidentially.
Want to start your counselling today?
Make an Appointment